|
Poker Book Reviews
One thing I’ve learned throughout my poker
readings is that the best-known tournament players tend to not write
instructional books very well. This is partially because they are well
known from their successes in poker tournaments, which are very different
from side games, and also because they are out of touch with what a beginning
player needs to learn. This is not to say that the great authors are not
also great players, but they tend to make their mark without parading
themselves around and talking about their tournament successes all the
time, the way T.J. Cloutier and Phil Hellmuth do.
I also recommend you learn at least two or three poker forms
well. For one thing, variety helps your continued interest in poker, and
also you can shun a less profitable hold ‘em table if all the idiots are
playing Omaha.
| The Five
Best Authors |
Five
Authors to Avoid |
| David Sklansky |
Ken Warren |
| Mason Malmuth |
Andy Nelson |
| Bob Ciaffone |
Phil Hellmuth,
Jr. |
| Stewart Reuben |
Mike Cappelletti |
| Ray Zee |
T.J. Cloutier |
The format of these reviews is as follows: Title
(Author) (Rating out of 10) [Book’s target skill level out of 5, 5 being
most advanced]: Review (Retail Price - click to buy at amazon.com)
Books for Beginners
Starting Out in Poker (Stewart Reuben) (9)
[0-2]: A very good book by a poker player who is also a talented writer.
Includes basic concepts and useful sections on many different forms of
poker, including some basic advice on big-bet hold ‘em. Though pricey for
a beginner’s book, it’s a great read. ($12.95)
Fundamentals of Poker (Mason Malmuth) (9) [0]:
A good book for the ultra-beginner. Teaches the basic rules of the most
popular forms of poker, including stud, hold ‘em and Omaha, and offers
correct basic strategy for each. Affordable, and a good read if you want
to start at the very bottom. ($5.95)
7-Card Stud: The Complete Course In Winning
(Roy West) (8) [1]: This is a good beginner’s guide to the game. Geared
towards medium and low-limit games, this book recommends tighter play than
one might expect, because it assumes most of the opponents are playing
fairly obviously. It includes advice on how to play varying ranks of
pairs, how to evaluate the quality of flush and straight draws, how to
conduct the betting with certain hands, the danger of two small pair, and
more. West also writes in a down-to-earth and friendly style, which may
make the book a nicer read for you. ($24.95)
Winning Low Limit Hold ‘em (Lee Jones) (7)
[1]: This is a similar text to Sklansky’s Hold ‘em Poker, but it is aimed
at a different audience: those who are playing in very loose games with
flop percentages over 50%. Although most games are tighter online than in
a casino or cardroom, it is still not difficult to find these types of
games online. Jones gives a good introduction to strategic concepts
(although his starting hand tables are flawed) and how to use the odds to
your advantage in a loose game. A good read for a beginner in
a loose hold ‘em game, but you must find better books to beat tougher
games where the real money is. ( $19.96)
Play Poker Like the Pros (Phil Hellmuth) (3)
[0]: This book is grossly mistitled. While it does show you some of the
strategies the pros use, the book is designed for someone who has never
played poker before. Also, though Hellmuth is an awesome tournament
player, he tends to be a moderate player at best in ring-games, and his
advice for beginning hold ‘em players is particularly bad. Although the
sections on other forms of poker provide decent introductions to those
games, Hellmuth offers bits of advice that directly contradict authors
like Sklansky and Malmuth that obviously know more about what they are
doing. I advise all of my opponents to read his strategy on limit and
no-limit hold ‘em, as it will cause them to go broke very quickly.
( $11.17)
General Poker Books:
The Theory of Poker (David Sklansky) (10)
[2-5]: This is easily the best book ever written on poker. Before this
classic, poker books were all of the ‘how-to’ variety, and most were
ineffective even at that task. Instead of telling you how to play a given
hand in a given situation, Sklansky instead highlights the theoretical
concepts that apply to all forms of poker in all situations at the table.
It includes extensive chapters on such vital ideas as position, free
cards, semi-bluffing, bluffing, check-raising, raising, heads-up play on
the last betting round, and much more. Don’t try to beat any difficult
poker game without reading this thoroughly. If you intend to play poker
seriously, you really need to own a copy and reread it many times. The
varying skill rating indicates that it can help players at all levels.
( $20.96)
Improve Your Poker (Bob Ciaffone) (9) [3]: An
excellent book on poker, focusing on limit and no-limit hold 'em, and
pot-limit Omaha. It’s geared towards someone with experience at
poker who is looking for extra edges in his game. This is written as a
collection of articles, with a large section of general thoughts about
poker, and short sections of specific concepts of hold ‘em, stud and
Omaha. Ciaffone discusses a lot of ideas, such as the number of players
in the pot, how to evaluate opponents, and avoiding basic problems with
your game, which are not discussed in most other poker literature. A must
read for the advancing player. ( $20.00)
Sklansky on Poker (David Sklansky) (9) [3-4]:
Another great book by Sklansky. Half of the book is devoted to essays on
strategic concepts in poker, and half of it is a strategy guide to the
game of Razz (seven card stud played for low). Because Razz is not played
much anymore, the excellent Razz section is not as useful as it could be.
The essays are somewhat in the theoretical mold of The Theory of Poker,
but deal with more specific situations and ideas. Unfortunately, the book
lacks the depth and length of Sklansky’s other works, so it is not quite
as valuable. ( $29.95)
Poker
Essays I, II, III
(Mason Malmuth) (9, 8, 9) [3-4]: There are three volumes of essays, but I
have grouped them into one review. Malmuth
clearly states that the primary goal of these books is to get the reader
to do a lot of thinking about the game. In that respect, he succeeds
triumphantly. Unfortunately, there is not too much direct poker
advice in these for $24.95 apiece. Each book also includes a section on cardroom management, which is not of a whole lot of use to a beginning
poker player. However, the hand analysis essays lead the
player on a good road towards analyzing his own play, which is an
important step towards improving poker skills. I definitely recommend
these books, but only for the player who already knows all the basics.
(For those interested primarily in tournament play, Malmuth has some
excellent tournament essays in the first book.)
( $19.96
(I),
$24.95 (II),
$19.96 (III))
Caro’s Fundamental Secrets of Winning Poker
(Mike Caro) (7) [2]: This is a fairly short book, but it contains a lot of
helpful advice. Caro writes in a unique ‘seminar’ style that helps
readers better understand some vital poker skills. It contains general
concepts as well as sections specific to draw, stud and hold ‘em. Caro
also includes some basic advice on tells, the focus of the next book.
(You can read some of Mike Caro's writing at
Poker1.com.)
($10.36)
Caro’s Book of Poker Tells (Mike Caro) (7)
[1-3]: This is the definitive work on the science of tells, which allow
you to use a player’s mannerisms to read the quality of his hand. Of
course, this is of very little use to the online player. Tells are also
more useful in draw or stud games than hold ‘em. The dollar values given
for the tells in this book are ridiculously inflated, so it is best to
just ignore them. At higher limits, many players are aware of the tells
in this book and are capable of reversing them, so this is generally only
of use to the low-stakes player. ( $17.47)
Hold ‘em Books
Hold ‘em Poker for Advanced Players (David
Sklansky, Mason Malmuth) (10) [4-5]: This is the best overall book on hold
‘em on the market. It covers advanced plays with a strong focus on
semi-bluffing and free card strategy. It is designed to be used by
players in $10/$20 and higher games, although it is also useful reading
for looser games. It also includes a very good section on short-handed
strategy. Must reading if you are planning to move up to higher stakes.
This book is also useful for tournament players, especially the
shorthanded advice.
( $20.96)
Small-Stakes Hold 'em (Ed Miller, David Sklansky, Mason Malmuth) (10)
[2-4]: The best available guide for beating low-limit hold 'em games.
Focuses on the ideas of pot equity, money and odds, and knocking players
out. Although it is geared to small-stakes players, even mid-stakes
regulars can pick up useful tips from it, and add to their win rate.
One big advantage of this book is that Miller is more forthright than most
authors about describing the magnitude of certain errors many players make
at the hold 'em table, which encourages the advice to stick in the
reader's head. Must reading for all hold 'em players. ($24.95)
Hold ‘em Poker (David Sklansky) (9) [1]:
Geared towards the beginning player, this takes you all the way from
learning how the game is played to somewhat advanced strategy.
Unfortunately, it has become a bit outdated, as the two-blind structure is
making games looser and creating more action. However, it still includes
excellent sections on what flops your hand is looking for, hand rankings,
and strategic considerations. ( $15.96)
Middle Limit Holdem Poker (Bob Ciaffone,
Jim Brier) (8) [4]: This book is geared at $10/$20 or higher games, but
the advice can be very useful for lower limits as well. It is
divided into chapters based on situation (betting round, action to you)
and each chapter includes a short strategy section before launching into a
series of questions where they describe your hand and how the betting has
proceeded, and ask you to make a decision to check, bet, fold, call or
raise in that situation. The book does not rate higher because while
it usually gives the best play against unknown opponents, you must take
other factors into consideration when facing familiar players, who may not
play typically. ( $25.00)
Inside
the Poker Mind
(John Feeney) (8) [3-4]: This is a fairly good book for the advancing hold
‘em player. It is not concerned with strategy so much as getting the
player to analyze and improve upon his plays. The book is arranged as a
collection of essays, whose usefulness ranges from excellent (“Do you pass
the AQ test”) to marginal (“A poker player in therapy”). Designed to be
read alongside other 2+2 books by Sklansky and Malmuth. It’s a good read for someone who is winning
consistently but looking to fix leaks in his game.
( $19.96)
Real
Poker II: The Play of Hands
(Roy Cooke) (8) [3]: This book is a collection of Roy Cooke's Card Player
articles that deal with his thought processes during hold 'em hands.
Cooke analyzes his own plays as well as the plays of others, both winning
and losing players, and gives you an idea of what you should be thinking
about when you play. Cooke is also not afraid to write about
mistakes he's made at the table, hoping you do not do the same. This
is a good read for the novice but advancing player who needs to know what
he should be thinking about during a hand, although his analysis is not as
thorough as Mason Malmuth's in his Poker Essays books.
($19.95)
The
Complete Book of Hold ‘em Poker
(Gary Carson) (8 and 4) [3]: Let me explain the book's two different
ratings. It is the best available guide for how to play in loose games,
which are the expert field of the author. The book includes extensive and
useful sections on starting hands, betting odds, drawing hands and made
hands, outs, and how to adjust to the composition of your game. However,
the book is not nearly as “complete” as the title would make it seem; it
includes little advice for turn or river play, and it does not include
much useful advice for playing in a tight game. It also tries to include
sections on pot-limit and no-limit games and tournament play, but these
are much too brief to be of any real use to the player. Thus, if you find
yourself in loose games and are looking for advice, this is a great read,
but don't try to beat a tough hold 'em game using this book as your only
guide. ( $10.47)
Other Poker Books
Pot-Limit and No-Limit Poker (Stewart Reuben,
Bob Ciaffone) (9) [4]: The ultimate guide for how to play in these
games. It requires a lot of prior poker knowledge, as much of the book is
structured in terms of what adjustments the advanced player should make
from his limit game strategies. The sections on big-bet hold ‘em and
pot-limit Omaha are particularly excellent, but the entire book is well
worth reading even if you do not expect to play a game like no-limit
lowball, as key big-bet poker concepts are scattered throughout. There is
also a tournament section and an appendix with odds. Aside from this,
there is no other work on big-bet poker worth buying, which helps
contribute to its high rating. ( $25.00)
Seven Card Stud for Advanced Players (David Sklansky, Mason Malmuth,
Ray Zee) (9) [4]: The best book available on 7-card stud. Its structure
is somewhat similar to the hold ‘em book, although it is divided by
betting rounds, with extensive sections on third through fifth streets,
including ante stealing, the danger of a paired door card, semi-bluffs,
buying free cards, and plenty more. Though it is geared at $15/$30 and
higher limits, the advice will be very useful at $3/$6 too. ( $23.96)
Tournament Poker for Advanced Players (David
Sklansky) (9) [3]: In my opinion, the only tournament poker book worth
reading. Just as The Theory of Poker taught theoretical concepts instead
of how-to advice, this book does the same for tournaments. It’s geared
towards teaching the reader how to adjust his normal ring-game strategy in
a tournament, so a working knowledge of how to play your poker form of
choice is required. The book evolves from basic to advanced strategies,
and includes a section of hand quizzes where you can put your newfound
knowledge to work. A must-read for serious tournament players.
( $23.96)
Omaha Holdem Poker (Bob Ciaffone) (9) [2]: The
definitive work on Omaha. Provides the player with a working knowledge of
how to play the game, based on a “what are you trying to build?”
approach. Ciaffone warns of danger Omaha hands such as bottom set and
queen-high flush draws, and shows how to properly evaluate starting
hands. All of these can be danger points for the beginning Omaha player.
It also includes a good section on pot-limit Omaha, which is augmented
very nicely by the Omaha section in the above book co-authored with
Reuben. I rate it only a 9, however, because the section on Omaha
high-low is very brief and contains only very basic strategy. ( $20.00)
High-Low Split Poker for Advanced Players (Ray
Zee) (9 and 8) [3]: Split into two sections for 7-Stud hi-lo and Omaha
hi-lo (rated respectively), this is the
best work currently available for either game, mainly because no other
books have been written by good authors on either of them. Zee is no
slouch, however: he knows the aim of high-low poker (winning the whole
pot) and builds around that focus. He discusses important ideas about
starting hands in 7-stud, how to recognize folding situations, when to jam
the pot, how to adjust your play in Omaha/8 based on the looseness of the
game, drawing to the nuts, when to raise and when to call with powerful
hands, and how to recognize when you’re beaten on the river. His Omaha/8
section is of more help to the advancing player, as he correctly
recognizes that the game does not require very much advice when 60% are
seeing the flop. ( $27.96)
Super/System: A Course in Power Poker
(Many
Authors) (8) [2-4]: This book is divided into six sections, which are
reviewed individually. The book was billed as the tell-all poker book
when it was initially printed many years ago, but has become outdated,
although it still contains a wealth of poker knowledge. ( $20.97)
- 5-card Draw (Mike Caro) (9) [2-4]: Caro is
the ultimate authority on draw poker, and this book is a great read on
the subject. Since draw is not played in most cardrooms anymore, the
advice is of limited use, but this is as complete a guide to winning at
the game as you will find.
- 7-card Stud (Chip Reese) (9) [2-3]: Aside
from the Sklansky/Malmuth/Zee book, this is the best work on 7-card stud
out there. With the sections on draw and hi-lo split with no qualifier
becoming outdated, this is probably the most useful section in the book.
- Lowball (Joey Hawthorne) (8) [2]: Provides
a good basic winning strategy for a game that is now completely extinct
in public cardrooms. Since there is not much literature on lowball,
this is probably good enough for your home game.
- Hi-Lo Split, No Qualifier (David Sklansky)
(9) [2-3]: This is an excellent guide for how to play the game, but
hi-lo games without qualifiers are almost never played with the
exception of hi-lo declare, and Sklansky’s section on the declare
variation of the game is good but brief.
- Limit Texas Hold ‘em (Bobby Baldwin) (7)
[1]: A decent guide to the game, although it is not as good as most
other hold ‘em literature. It also suffers because it was written for
the old one-blind structure and has not been updated to meet the times,
as correct strategy for the two-blind game is often different.
- No-Limit Hold ‘em
(Doyle Brunson) (7) [1-2]: A pretty good, but not great guide to the
game. Other than Pot-Limit and No-Limit Poker, this is the best
available guide to no-limit.
Doyle’s advice is questionable in some cases, however. He prefers A-K
to A-A, for example. Still, well worth reading for serious
players.
The Psychology of Poker
(Alan Schoonmaker) (7)
[2]: An interesting and very different book on poker. It focuses not on
strategic concepts of the game, but on how different players approach and
think about poker. Contains extensive descriptions of four groups of
players: loose-aggressive, loose-passive, tight-passive, and
tight-aggressive (the winning style that all the professionals use), and
tells you how to adjust your strategies when facing different players.
Also contains advice for players who do not fit the tight-aggressive mold
to help them get there. It’s a useful book, but it contains a lot of
filler. ( $19.96)
Championship No-Limit and Pot-Limit Hold ‘em (T.J.
Cloutier, Tom McEvoy) (5) [2]: This book has been widely praised as the
bible of how to play these games, but it is frankly not all that useful.
It does contain good advice to play tightly at all times, especially in
the middle stages of tournaments, but Cloutier and McEvoy are horrible
writers, and their advice often seems counterintuitive. They advise you
to do very little bluffing on the flop lest you get caught, and talk more
about how to play specific hands than any general concepts. If you learn
better by being told what to do than what to think about when making a
decision, this is the book for you. ($29.95)
Championship Omaha (T.J. Cloutier, Tom McEvoy)
(3) [2]: This book reinforced my notion that these authors are just not
very good at writing poker books. Although some of the advice in this
book is useful, Championship Omaha is inferior to Ciaffone’s Omaha book in
every way, and offers nothing new over it except that the strategy
sections are constantly interrupted by irrelevant discussions about hands
that Cloutier and McEvoy played in Texas hold ‘em tournaments. It does
contain some decent advice on selecting starting hands, but the advice on
flop play and beyond is not very useful. If this were the only Omaha book
on the market, it might receive a higher rating, but readers of the
Ciaffone book have no reason to buy this. ($29.95)
Copyright 2003-2004
WinningOnlinePoker.com. Have any feedback on the
site? Send it here.
|